COMMENTS
...very informative and thanks for sharing, good info. I now have a direction to go in trying to figure out what my issues are with this numbing and tingling firing up on my arm.
Posted by J Miller on 11/18/2008 at 2:35:PM
You're welcome J, hopefully you're not in too much pain/discomfort, this can really be a lifestyle changer until you get it under control.
Posted by Rich Leach on 11/18/2008 at 2:47:PM
when are you going to post the other parts to this series??? I'm
dyin' ova here!
Posted by Roger Rabbit on 01/25/2009 at 5:55:PM
... sorry for the delay, I got busy with work stuff. I'm planning
on cranking these out now, I just posted the Correct Diagnosis
blog, hopefully the next one is only a few days out. Thanks for
your patience.
Rich
Posted by Rich Leach on 01/28/2009 at 8:22:PM
Rich -- what is traction without downward pressure? Is that the
over the door traction devices? Thanks
Posted by Art CR on 02/27/2009 at 5:58:PM
Art-
You are correct, when I mention traction without downward pressure I'm referring to traction applied with a device like the over the door traction unit or if you're on the table with a massage therapist sometimes they'll use a towel around your head and slowly lift and pull at the same time, literally pulling your head away from your body. A device like the Pronex unit applies its force by forcing pressure against your shoulders to force your head and spine up, which may aggravate certain conditions. I'm almost done with my next blog entry which just happens to cover traction devices; stay tuned!
Posted by Rich Leach on 02/28/2009 at 9:02:AM
Hi Rich: Thanks for taking the time to write these articles. I'm
in my early 40s and have cervical radiculopathy. Started 4 months
ago. I've been doing chiropractic, some acupuncture, even medical
laser therapy. Still having major problems. Anti-inflammatory
drugs don't seem to do anything. I'm wearing a soft cervical
collar which helps a bit, in terms of taking some pressure off. I
look forward to your next installments in the series. Thanks again.
Posted by Andrew Starling on 03/02/2009 at 4:03:PM
Hi Andrew -- I'm in the same boat. It started with a hugh pain
in my arm, then had heaviness in my shoulder, then tingling in
my thumb and forefinger. Then the tingles went away, but had
lots of pain radiating down the arm, now 4 month later, I get
some pain off and on, no tingling, but overall weakness in the
arm. I've been going to PT, but not really sure than is working.
I'm wondering -- what are the signs that it's gettting better?
How long do people have this?
Posted by Art CR on 03/02/2009 at 6:20:PM
Hey Rich: This is actually the 3rd time I've had these symptoms.
They started in 2007. I would have trouble for about 4 months,
then the problem goes away for 4 months, then returns. I was
doing chiropractic and a bit of acupuncture before. Cannot say if
the symptoms disappeared naturally over time, or if the
chiropractic and acupuncture helped. If anyone has a magic bullet
that will get rid of this let me know. Currently, I am waiting to
have a nerve conduction study done at the hospital. I've had a CT
scan which indicated bulging discs at the base of my neck and
some osteophyte issues. Maybe some disc degeneration also. Sounds
like I'm in my 80s, but as I mentioned I'm early 40s. If anyone
has some good exercises or any suggestions please let me know. I
would rather be proactive about this problem rather than sitting
around. I have similar problems with numbness radiating down my
right forearm and into my thumb and index finger. Pain around the
right shoulder, pectoral region. Soreness running down the right
side of my cervical spine. I'm right-handed and it makes work
difficult. If I find anything that really helps I will post here.
Best wishes to everyone.
Posted by Andrew Starling on 03/02/2009 at 8:24:PM
@Andrew- You're welcome, sorry to hear you're dealing with this
problem too. My next few series are definitely going to be of
value to you, will try to get them out by this weekend.
@Art- Have you had x-rays? If your discs have completely
deteriorated you may be into something different. When I saw my
x-rays we (the doc and I) still saw some disc left, so our plan
was to work on bring fluid into the area (traction) and
strengthening the surrounding muscles (isometrics) and wow, after
about a week I really noticed a difference. Again, I've got
another blog entry coming out discussing all of that. So sorry
it's taken me so long! I've been busy with work, and with the
economy the way it is I've been trying to stay focused. Hang in
there!
Rich
Posted by Rich Leach on 03/03/2009 at 8:53:AM
Hi Rich --I initially had a big pain in the arm, like you, a
knock your socks off pain. Then that subsided, and what remained
was pain/heaviness in the shoulder blade. Then that subsided in a
few days and I was left with buzzing/tingles in the forefinger
and thumb. I had a MRI that showed the disk hitting the nerve at
C6.
Then I started PT and the numbness pretty much stopped around
that time. Had some nerve tests and they were ok. After two weeks
of PT, I had tremendous pain in the forearm. That went away after
about one month and a new therapist who took a different approach
with my neck and gave me stretches and exercises, which the
initial therapist did not do.
Now in what is my 4th month of this, what appears to remain is a
general feeling of fatigue in the arm and some heaviness and
maybe tingling in the back of the shoulder.
I only have a few sessions of PT left, and am starting
acupuncture on Saturday to see if that helps...everyone says it
can't hurt. Then I'm headed back to the doctor mid-month to
report on where I am to see what is next, which he said would be
a cortisone shot in the neck which would reduce inflammation.
I am hoping the doctor will prescribe more PT, rather than a
shot, but I was told the insurance company would have to review
my case beyond 24 sessions of PT, which I am almost at now.
Posted by Art CR on 03/03/2009 at 7:50:PM
@Art-
Have you visited with a qualified massage therapist? Not that a
physical therapist won't help you, but my biggest success with
nailing down this thing is described here:
http://www.cfsnap.com/cfsnap.cfm?webtool=8-Steps-to-Beating-Cervical-Radiculopathy-Correct-Diagnosis
Hope this helps!
Rich
Posted by Rich Leach on 03/04/2009 at 9:33:AM
Rich, I started with a crick in my neck, within a week I
experienced and still do excruciating pain in my right shoulder
under the blade up around under my arm and shoots to my right
elbow. That continues and then thumb, index and middle finger
tingling. Now numbness and tingling in my right arm. I've seen
my GP and see an orthopedist this week. Xray appears to
indicate a possible disc problem. None of the meds rx'd have
helped. Your thoughts?
Posted by Mary Mosby on 03/08/2009 at 2:45:PM
@Mary- Sorry to hear about your pains. Remember, I'm not a
doctor, but make sure you continue to tell whomever you're
working with (doctor, ortho, massage, etc) about your specifics,
especially the thumb, index and middle fingers. The first few
fingers usually indicate an impingement of the ulnar nerve, and
when the outside fingers are affected it's usually the radial
nerve (or vice versa.... I told you I wasn't a doctor ;-)) What
I'm saying is those symptoms sound very specific. I know they can
also do nerve conduction tests as well, so see what the experts
tell you and hang in there. BTW, I'm also done with my cervical
traction blog, will be posting it shortly....
Posted by Rich Leach on 03/08/2009 at 10:21:PM
I went back to my doctor and basically he told me that the next
step after the two months of PT that I already had would be a
cortisone shot in the neck. At this point, I have to say that I
think I'll do this because the arm is simply not the same as it
was -- it doesn't appear that the pressure has been removed after
traction and PT. I feel for everyone, as this is very difficult
to deal with.
Posted by Art CR on 04/05/2009 at 11:12:PM
@Art. If you do get the cortisone shot would you be so kind as to
post about what is involved? That may be something I will have to
have in the near future and I would like a first-hand account to
make a judgement call. These days I'm having physiotherapy and
acupuncture twice a week. Still waiting for an MRI. Had a nerve
conduction study that indicated there is definitely a problem.
I've had symptoms over 5 months now. Right arm. Mostly shoulder,
forearm, wrist, top of hand, thumb and index finger. Been off
work for over 3 months. Thanks for any insight you can provide.
Posted by Andrew Starling on 04/13/2009 at 3:11:PM
I've had the symptoms for about that same amount of time -- its
very, very difficult, and has morphed and changed throughout.
Lately, my arm just doesn't "feel right" any longer. Meaning the
wrist feels odd, the forearm off, I have pain now in my shoulder.
Overall tired arm. I beginning to wonder if its something like
Lyme, even though the MRI showed a disk problem. There are a
number of places on the internet that talk about the shot -- yif
ou can do a search you'll find them.
Posted by Art CR on 04/13/2009 at 9:20:PM
Thank-you for the information. I have not been diagnosed yet but my symptoms
started in my Rt shoulder blade and kink in my neck too. But then after the
pain/knot in the shoulder was gone I began having pain where my shoulder and
arm attach that radiated down my arm until it reached my thumb. My thumb is
basically numb all the time and then I get shooting pain down my arm with irritation
and for what ever reason it wants to start again. Coughing is horrid. To make
things worse I have a long hx or non/rarely treated neck pain, plus in October I
fractured my clavicle which may also be a factor, I had noted some of these
symptoms while it healed but nothing to this extent. I have always done well with
ignoring pain but when my thumb is numb all the time, something is wrong. My
doctor did an MRI which shows a extrusion type herniation on the left at C5-6 and
other various degenerative changes (could possibly be related to this) at every level
except C-7 T-8. I had a Nerve Conduction Test which they say showed nothing but
one nerve shows that there may be some future problem (I still need a copy of it). I
was able to be into another doctor in my office who referred my to PT the
herniation. Hmm.. She seemed to miss what side is bothering me. I have had luck
in the past for other things with PT and I am hopeful. I thought that they
recommend traction though. Although they are working on loosening up the neck
with manual traction through massage.
Posted by Beth AW on 04/22/2009 at 8:51:PM
@Beth. Sorry to hear you have this problem also. If you read the
above comments you will get a sense of my particular issues. My
nerve conduction test indicated I had some issues. Lately I have
been doing PT, with cervical spine traction and some acupuncture
twice a week. I have to say (and my fingers are crossed while I
say it) that the traction seems to be helping a little. Even if
the vertebrae are opening up by a fraction of an inch, maybe some
pressure is being taken of the nerve root (around C7 I think).
Rich was mentioning on the section about home traction that he
thought it helped him the most out of all the home devices he
tried. Perhaps some form of traction would help you too? I hope
so. I'm going to stick with my current PT, get an MRI, see what
the doctor says about the results, and hope to avoid the surgeon.
Posted by Andrew Starling on 04/23/2009 at 11:27:AM
@Beth - Trust me, I've been where you are and I know how
difficult it can be. I apologize as I've gotten busy recently and
I was going to finish out these videos on traction devices, but I
may jump ahead and actually shoot some of the isometric exercises
that helped me a lot. Unless your docs have a specific reason to
avoid them, isometrics are great for strengthening some of the
smaller muscles in the neck as well as the primary muscles.
Because I had a slight muscle imbalance isometrics helped me
stabilize and even-out the tension on the vertebrae and probably
lessened the nerve impingement. It probably didn't do much to
directly benefit the health of that particular joint but it
relieved the discomfort right away without causing any further
joint deterioration. The traction may help more with the actual
health of the joint, the discs and the natural fluids. And of
course, only your doctor can accurately diagnose all of this,
especially considering your fractured clavicle injury.
I'll get to the next video as quickly as I can, hang in there!
Posted by Rich Leach on 04/23/2009 at 12:04:PM
@Art & Rich-Thanks for the encouragement. I did question
traction at PT and they want to get the inflamation/tension in
my neck & shoulders down and some strengthening in my
neck/back/shoulder before I move to a traction device. She is
changing the exercises as they have been aggrevating my
problems. Too many issues complicating each other. Silly
question, once the shooting pain is controlled does the numbness
go away?
@Rich I really appreciate this info. I truly understand the
delays as it appears that you are working FT too. I would
probably never be able to find the time to do something like
this so you deserve a HUGE thanks!
Posted by Beth AW on 04/24/2009 at 4:08:PM
I had the cortisone shots. The first was like it never happened
-- no problems at all, and maybe it helped slightly over a few
week period. The second has not been good. I was sick due to the
anesthesia, and then the overall discomfort actually increased in
the arm, shoulder, wrist, forearm, scapula, fingers, after the
shot. It's only day two, but this is something that was supposed
to be a relief, very, very disappointing. Hope others are having
more success.
Posted by Art CR on 05/23/2009 at 3:31:PM
Hi Rich,
I have been reading through your's and everyone's postings and
am pretty sure that I have CR as well. The doctor diagnosed
rotator cuff tendonitis last Monday and PT for that. I went to
him because of numbness and tingling that started Sunday. I had
the pain in shoulder beginning mid May but just thought I had
pulled something.. Had two adjustments that strengthened my arm
resistance briefly. I will be printing off the info and giving
to everyone this week. I don't think that the PT is helping and
could be making matters worse. I am not in excruciating pain
nor have I been which is a blessing compared to the many
postings. I pray everyone finds relief and healing soon.
Posted by Ossie Brewer on 06/14/2009 at 8:46:AM
Hi Rich, I read your story with interest. I've been suffering
from tingling and numbness in my right hand since 2005 (after a
fall.) I had CTS release surgery in 2007 and the burning
stopped, but I was really disappointed when the tingling and
numbness returned. I've had pain in my neck and right shoulder
radiating down to my thumb and fingers since. I finally went to
the Dr to have it diagnosed. I got some exercises (which
admittedly helped the pain, tho not the tingling & numbness) and
Xrays which show no arthritis or degeneration so I now have to
go get nerve conduction testing. The elbow pain and numbness are
INCREDIBLY obnoxious and annoying. HOWEVER...I saw your post
about massaging the neck through the front, and tada, it
actually helped. I'll tell my doc about it and thank you for the
info.
Posted by Metal Haid on 08/26/2009 at 11:45:PM
@ Metal-
... find yourself a massage therapist who knows "St. Johns". My
understanding is that most massage therapists are trained in
"Swedish" which is different and the few who know St.Johns really
helped me the most. Specifically, you need to get those
longissimus muscles on the front of your spine to relax and
release, they should feel smooth and not like "roast beef" (which
is how my massage guy described mine). Hope this helps, and I'm
really trying to find some time to post the isometric exercises
as they really help stabilize the neck and spine muscles, taking
tension off of those longissimus muscles. Will shoot for the next
few weeks.... Hang in there!
Posted by Rich Leach on 08/27/2009 at 10:05:AM
Hi Rich and thank you for your information. I was wondering how
long did it take for you to get over your cervical radiculopathy
or do you still suffer with it? I want to get over this as soon
as possible and get on with my life. I do not have the pain part
but I do have the tingling numb thing which is extremely
aggravating. Thanks again.
Posted by terri ann on 04/08/2010 at 11:05:PM
Hi Terri Ann - Sorry to hear that you're dealing with this. I
really believe that a combination of readjusting my workspace,
isometrics resistance and massage therapy helped me get through
my CR. Once I started the massage I noticed immediate relief, but
it took a few weeks of the isometrics to stop the tingling. Your
situation may be greater or less than what I was dealing with,
but I still have and use the traction devices about once a week
(especially that inversion table, I love that thing) and I'm one
of the few folks who, not that I work out with weights 5-6 days a
week but I stretch my entire body every day. I just don't know of
any other person who stretches this consistently, and it's helped
me with a whole bunch of issues so once you get your condition
under control consider a daily stretching regimen (make sure
you're well enough first, stretching an irritated joint path will
actually make matters worse!) Good luck and keep the rest of us
posted on your progress :-)
Posted by Rich Leach on 04/08/2010 at 11:13:PM
Hi Rich, was kind of massage therapy do you suggest? I am
definitely considering this treatment. I have just started
physical therapy as well. I do have a nerve compression at C7.
No severe pain or tingling other than soreness and tightness in
the right side of my neck, but the muscle atrophy in my right
triceps is very tough to cope with. I have not worked out at the
gym in approx 5 months since I started having the symptoms since
I didn't want to make things worse and until I received a
diagnosis. Did you or anyone else have any type of muscle loss?
Did the strength come back?
Your blog and the info it provides is great! I appreciate it. I
wish you and everyone else the best of health and full recovery!
Posted by Michael M on 04/13/2010 at 6:52:PM
@Michael ~ Sorry to learn about your suffering. The massage
therapist I was using was versed in "St. Johns", not quite sure
if that's the name of the discipline or a style or what. My
understanding is that the other, more mainstream style is known
as "Swedish" (which I find more relaxing and comfortable; the St.
Johns seemed to approach massage from a more clinical point of
view). Ask around because I could be way off with this, but you
could also try giving Bill and Sally a call (read my other
posting:
http://www.cfsnap.com/cfsnap.cfm?webtool=8-Steps-to-Beating-Cervical-Radiculopathy-Correct-Diagnosis
) and let us know how you progress.
Posted by Rich Leach on 04/14/2010 at 8:42:AM
I have worked 50 hours plus on the computer for about 12 years.
Now only working about 18 a week, thank god.I have just been
diagnoised through an MRI with 2 torn ligaments in my rotar
cuff. Got a Cortizone shot in the shoulder it helped about 85%,
except when I've fit my 18 hours into 3 days and then I will
hurt for a few days. Went back to Dr. after 4 weeks and told him
I have pain, he gave me another shot. I proceeded to get a pain
in my upper arm,(an arm that tingles and radiates into my thumb)
This arm got so bad after that 2nd shot I now cannot lift it as
if it is locked up.Today had another MRI the tears are worse and
with the 2nd MRI they see a spur that may be damaging the
ligiments. Had a nerve induction done, have carpel and also have
Cervical Radiculopathy, which explains the tingleing and burning
in arm. My doctor who is a Physiatrist does not seem knowlegable
that this damage cld of been cased from my computer use and I
feel confident is is.I live in Cocoa Florida, does anyone know
how I can track down a knowledgable Orthopedic Surgeon or any
recommended Doctor?
Posted by Delores Rutherford on 05/03/2010 at 6:03:PM
So glad to find this information on the web! I have been
suffering with cervical radiculopathy for just over three months
now. I am 41. The MRI showed bulging discs at C5-6 and C6-7 and
the EMG showed acute C7 radiculopathy. My problem is almost
exactly as you described but mine is down my right arm and I have
had permanent numbness in my index finger, thumb, and middle
finger for just over 2 months. I have done PT, massage, 3
acupuncture visits so far, and am doing home traction. The
neurosurgeon said I would have to have both discs removed. I
want to try everything before I resort to surgery. I am
wondering if you could share the isometric exercises. I was
unable to find them on here. I also was interested in knowing
what supplements you used. Thanks so much!!!!!!!! It feels good
to know that others out there have suffered through the same thing!
Posted by Tammie Fraley on 06/13/2010 at 10:36:PM
Hi Tammie, sorry to hear about your condition but it sounds like
you're giving it your all to avoid the surgery. Things have been
rather busy for me lately but the good news is that I've not had
any more symptoms either, so evidently something is working for
me, which I'll be sharing on this blog in the next few days.
Thanks for your patience and I'll try to address everything for
you shortly. Hang in there!
Posted by Rich Leach on 06/14/2010 at 9:41:AM
tres interessant
Posted by toudas aouadi on 08/22/2010 at 8:28:AM
Hello,
I was just diagnosed with cervical radiculopathy C6 after being
treated for several weeks for carpal tunnel syndrome without
improvement. EMG today could not validate the carpal tunnel
syndrome, but was definitive for CR.
Was anyone else misdiagnosed with CTS? I don't have any
shoulder pain but I do get pain in my forearms and
numbness/tingling in my hands (palm, thumb, forefinger) which is
consistent with CTS.
I am to continue with Oc Therapy for Ergo evaluation and posture
and am now prescribed PT for neuromuscular stretches,
strengthening and traction.
Posted by Stephanie Alexander on 09/01/2010 at 6:05:PM
Hi Stephanie -
Sorry to learn of your situation. It was my understanding that
the 2 conditions you speak of are actually very definitive, even
though they share a few symptoms. I'm a little surprised that
your doc couldn't make the distinction.... I know that if your
thumb and forefinger tingle vs. your other fingers it indicates
trouble with your radial nerve, the other your ulnar nerve, or
vice-versa. Regardless the traction helped me as did the
strengthening with isometric contractions, which reminds me, I
owe this blog my preso on isometrics... maybe this weekend.
Anyway circle back with your doc, have you tried an orthopedist?
Rich
Posted by Rich Leach on 09/02/2010 at 10:13:PM